Imagine Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, and Tom Holland standing together once again, facing a threat powerful enough to destroy entire universes. After the emotional success of Spider-Man: No Way Home, Marvel fans want to see the three Spider-Men reunite, but this time on a much larger battlefield.
With Doctor Doom entering the Marvel Cinematic Universe in Avengers: Doomsday, could the multiverse bring all three versions of Peter Parker together again?
Although Marvel has not confirmed this crossover, the multiverse storyline offers several exciting possibilities. Here is how the three Spider-Men could potentially unite against Doctor Doom.
1. Doctor Doom Could Become the Reason Their Universes Collide
The biggest clue comes from the multiverse itself.
In Spider-Man: No Way Home, Doctor Strange’s spell causes visitors from different universes to enter Tom Holland’s Peter Parker’s reality. This establishes that separate versions of Spider-Man can meet when the boundaries between universes become unstable.
Now imagine a similar situation on a much larger scale.
Doctor Doom could attempt to control or manipulate the multiverse, triggering a chain of events that threatens multiple realities. Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man could be protecting his own world when it becomes endangered, while Andrew Garfield’s Peter Parker could face a similar crisis in his universe.
Meanwhile, Tom Holland’s Spider-Man could become involved through events in his own reality.
If Doom’s actions cause these worlds to collide, the three heroes could find themselves fighting the same enemy.
This is a fan theory, not a confirmed plot detail, but it would provide a natural explanation for bringing the three Spider-Men together.
2. Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man Could Be the First to Encounter Doom
Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man represents the original modern live-action Spider-Man era for many fans.
His return in No Way Home showed that his Peter Parker had continued living his life after the events of his original trilogy. He had grown older, gained experience, and learned to deal with personal loss.
One possible theory is that Tobey’s Spider-Man could be among the first heroes to experience the consequences of an incursion, where two universes threaten to collide.
If Doctor Doom’s actions put his reality in danger, Tobey’s Peter might attempt to protect his world before discovering that the threat extends far beyond anything he has previously faced.
His experience could also make him a mentor to the other Spider-Men, especially if the three eventually have to make difficult decisions about saving their respective universes.
However, reports of Tobey’s involvement in Doomsday remain unconfirmed by Marvel.
3. Andrew Garfield’s Spider-Man Could Get the Comeback He Deserves
Andrew Garfield’s Spider-Man has one of the most emotionally complicated histories of the three versions.
In The Amazing Spider-Man 2, Peter loses Gwen Stacy, a tragedy that profoundly affects his character. During No Way Home, he reveals that he became angrier and more aggressive after losing her.
Helping Tom Holland’s Peter save MJ gives Andrew’s character an opportunity to confront his past and find a measure of healing.
A future crossover could build on that development.
Imagine Andrew’s Spider-Man encountering a situation where he cannot save everyone. Instead of allowing his grief to control him, he could draw on the lessons he learned from the other Peters.
This would give him a meaningful emotional arc rather than simply bringing him back for a nostalgic cameo.
Marvel has not confirmed his return in Doomsday, but his character has plenty of unfinished storytelling potential.
4. Tom Holland’s Spider-Man Could Connect the Other Two
Tom Holland’s Peter Parker occupies a different position from the other two Spider-Men.
After No Way Home, the world forgets his identity, leaving him without the personal support system he previously relied on. His future story begins with a more isolated Peter who must build his life again.
That makes his potential role in a multiversal crossover particularly interesting.
If his universe faces a threat from Doctor Doom, he could be forced to seek help from people who understand what it means to be Spider-Man.
Tobey’s experience and Andrew’s emotional resilience could complement Tom’s determination and willingness to sacrifice himself for others.
Together, they could represent three different stages of Peter Parker’s journey: youthful responsibility, hard-earned wisdom, and the struggle to overcome loss.
Their reunion would therefore have the potential to offer more than spectacular action. It could explore how three versions of the same person respond differently to responsibility.
5. Could Loki Bring All Three Spider-Men Together?
Loki offers another interesting possibility.
At the end of Loki Season 2, the God of Mischief takes responsibility for holding the branching timelines together. His story establishes his extraordinary connection to the multiverse.
If Doctor Doom threatens the stability of multiple realities, Loki could potentially become involved in the attempt to prevent their destruction.
A theoretical scenario could see Loki helping heroes understand the multiversal crisis, with the three Spider-Men eventually joining the larger fight.
However, there is no confirmed evidence that Loki will recruit all three Spider-Men in Doomsday. This remains a possible storyline rather than an established connection.
6. Could the Reunion Happen in Avengers: Secret Wars Instead?
There is another important possibility: Marvel might save the full reunion for Avengers: Secret Wars.
The 2015 Secret Wars comic-book storyline features a reality assembled from fragments of different worlds under Doctor Doom’s rule. Its multiversal setting provides a natural opportunity for characters from separate universes to meet.
An MCU adaptation could use a similar concept, bringing together heroes who have survived the destruction or merging of their realities.
That could give all three Spider-Men a reason to reunite without requiring them to appear together in Doomsday.
It would also allow Marvel to give the crossover greater emotional weight by building toward it across multiple films.
Neither the three-Spider-Man reunion nor this specific storyline has been officially confirmed.
Final Verdict: Will All Three Spider-Men Return?
The idea of Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, and Tom Holland fighting together again is one of the most exciting possibilities for Marvel’s multiverse storyline.
Doctor Doom’s introduction creates opportunities for a conflict that extends beyond a single universe. Loki’s connection to branching timelines provides another possible narrative link, while Secret Wars offers a comic-book precedent for bringing different realities together.
But fans should remember that a compelling theory is not the same as an official announcement. None of the three Spider-Men has been confirmed as part of a reunion in Avengers: Doomsday.
If Marvel eventually brings them together, the biggest question will not simply be how they fight Doctor Doom. It will be whether three different versions of Peter Parker can work together when the fate of their worlds is at stake.
For now, the multiverse leaves the door open, and fans will have to wait for Marvel’s next announcement to discover whether the legendary trio reunites.